I will start by saying the following 3 points.
1) I am not discussing free speech. Let me repeat that, in slightly different words, for those of you who are already jumping at the urge to lecture me on our bill of rights. I AM NOT TALKING ABOUT FREE SPEECH! I am a lawyer, who has, more likely than not, read more articles and cases on the topic of free speech, and written more papers on the topic, than you have or likely ever will. And for those who know more than I, kudos. Free speech is not the point of this article.
2) This particular blog is not a democratic, republican, independent, libertarian, Ron Paulblican etc. point of view. It's an American point of view.
3) I am not arguing over the subject matter/incident for which the protests in Albuquerque, New Mexico began. In fact, I will give a quick synopsis for those who are unaware of the current events happening there. Please, feel free to research more on the topic, I am simply hitting the main points here.
- On March 16, 2014, the Albuquerque Police Department had a three hour standoff with a homeless man, 38-year-old James Boyd, for illegally camping. Boyd reportedly had both a mental illness and criminal history. After the standoff, Boyd picked up his belongings to leave. Instead of letting him move on peacefully, the officers fired a flash bang, a taser, a bean bag rifle, two rifles, and released a police dog on Boyd. James Boyd died in the hospital the next day.
- All this was recorded by the police's own helmet cams - one of the first departments in the country to require officers to wear cameras.
- According to BBC News and the Albuquerque Journal, the Albuquerque Police Department "has been involved in 37 shootings, 24 of them fatal, since 2010...[and] critics say it is far too many for a department serving a city of about 555,000."
- Protests have erupted all over Albuquerque as an outcry against police brutality. Understandably.
To be clear: 1) I support free speech, 2) I am simply arguing as an American with no political affiliation, 3) I absolutely understand the outrage that the protesters feel over this incident, and police brutality in general.
Now...to my point.
Earlier today, I saw a
video of a Marine and a Soldier chasing after a motorcycle protester who was flying the American Flag upside down.
The same man who filmed the video, has additional social media posts showing other protesters who were holding the American flag upside down.
Immediately, the focus of the protest, police brutality, was lost to me. All the good these people were trying to do, by standing up against governmental abuse, seemed null and void in my mind. I was outraged that people would so freely fly the American flag upside down! Did they not know what it meant? Did they not know that doing so was extremely disrespectful?!?!
Then I thought...."OMG! Maybe they don't?!?!" And that thought made me disheartened. So here it goes.
THE AMERICAN FLAG SHOULD ALWAYS BE FLOWN WITH THE UNION UP.
The American flag is a symbol of reverence. This does not mean a blind allegiance or unquestioning worship, but rather, a respect for our national heritage. It signifies the sacrifices made for our country and pride for our nation. It exemplifies our good fortune to live in a country where we are able to freely express our opinions, and is used ceremoniously as a symbol of respect - whether for a great national event or as an homage to a fallen soldier, draped over the coffin, to represent a true hero.
The American flag should never be flown upside down. The United States Code carves out an exception, dubbed the "
Flag Code." The Flag Code states, "The flag should never be displayed with the union down, except as a signal of dire distress in instances of extreme danger to life or property." When displayed for the correct reasons, it is not a sign of disrespect in any way, shape or form. When displayed for incorrect reasons, it is a complete and utter sign of disrespect towards our country. And this includes reasons such as whether or not you like the President, the Congress, the Judiciary, the policies being passed, the lack of regulation on welfare...whatever the case may be. You do not fly the American flag upside down, but for instances of extreme distress.
Hey Albuquerquians ("ABQ's")! It's your city's police squad that committed this act. It's your city's police squad that has such a high percentage of fatalities in shootings, for such a low population of residents. Those of you flying the American flag upside down are not in a situation of "extreme danger to life or property" for which flying the American flag upside down is warranted. Now, James Boyd could have flown the flag upside down when he was threatened, and he would have every right to do so. You ABQ's doing so now, is simply a sign of utter disrespect for this country. You flying the American flag upside down has now distracted me, and I'm sure many others, on the stance you were initially trying to make.
You know what you can do right now? Thank your lucky stars that you live in America where you can fly our flag upside down and not be arrested. Funny...you want to disrespect our country by flying our flag upside down, yet take advantage of all the protections we have to offer, like not be arrested for doing so???? Quite a conundrum, isn't it?
Bottom line. Yes, you do have the "right" to display our American flag upside down in protest, but just because you have the right to do so, doesn't mean that you should.
If you want to protest, then protest. We live in such an amazing country that we are able to do so. However, you disrespect this country and our rich national heritage (not to mention the men and women that have fought and died for this country, and continue to fight and die for this country), when you fly our American flag upside down. Please....please find other ways to protest. If not for the sake of making your point known to the Albuquerque Police Department, then for the sake of this country, and those that fight to protect your freedoms. FLY OUR AMERICAN FLAG RIGHT SIDE UP!